No humour, please: France’s Hollande under fire for cracking jokes

Who said the French had no sense of humour? Their president, François Hollande, certainly does. With a reputation for wisecracks, Hollande has earned the nickname of Monsieur Petites-Blagues (Mr Little Jokes). According to the French media, the Socialist politician had to force himself to stop making jokes during his presidential campaign. But now that he is safely ensconced in the Élysée palace, his old habits seem to be returning to the fore. In the past few weeks, his bons mots have got the right-wing opposition all worked up.


The latest jokey episode - caught on camera, of course - occurred at the Paris Farm Show over the weekend. Hollande, who was there for the first time as president, was chatting to a group of children when one of them exclaimed that she had “never seen Nicolas Sarkozy”. Hollande shot back, quick as a flash: “Oh well, you won’t see him any more!” Cue much hilarity from the presidential delegation.


Hollande making the joke at the Paris Farm Show on February 23rd.


Needless to say, the right-wing opposition failed to see the funny side. Sarkozy’s former campaign spokeswoman and ecology minister, Nathalie Kosciusko-Morizet, slammed the quip as an “insult to the millions of French people who voted for Nicolas Sarkozy”, seeing it as proof that Hollande is “obsessed” with his predecessor. Another former minister, Luc Chatel, first expressed his disapproval by calling on Hollande to act more presidentially. He then decided to fight fire with fire during an appearance on the TV show Le Grand Journal on Monday night. In the course of the discussion, a journalist remarked that a former comedian, Beppe Grillo, had taken a massive 20% of the vote in the Italian election. Chatel immediately shot back with “In France, we have a comedian who took 51% of the vote”, in a clear reference to Hollande. Incidentally, no one laughed.


Nicolas Sarkozy himself has now reacted to the slight. In off the record comments reported by Le Parisien newspaper on Monday, he purportedly described Hollande’s one-liner as "so petty". The whole episode comes as Sarkozy is rumoured to be thinking of running for France’s top job again in 2017, a political subtext that has escaped nobody. But the former president is no stranger to controversy at the Paris Farm Show himself. It was there, in 2008, that he insulted a man who refused to shake his hand, with the now infamous line “Get lost, you idiot!”


Hollande’s other recent joke touched slightly less of a nerve. Commenting on the surprise resignation of Pope Benedict XVI, Hollande decided to try a little humour. After declaring solemnly that the Catholic Church should be left to sort out the details of the pope’s succession, he suddenly quipped, “We will not be fielding a candidate”. Sarkozy’s former interior minister, Claude Guéant, was quick to criticise Hollande’s little repartee. “Making a joke about such a dignified decision is inappropriate”, he grumbled.


Still, the president may have competition in the humour department. The day of the pope’s resignation, Hollande’s own minister for older people, Michèle Delaunay, sent out the following tweet with the French hashtags #Age and #EmploidesSeniors (jobs for older people): "I have to admit that, rightly or wrongly, Benedict XVI failed to consult me before taking his decision”.


She later deleted the tweet.

Comments or opinions expressed on this blog are those of the individual contributors only, and do not necessarily represent the views of FRANCE 24. The content on this blog is provided on an "as-is" basis. FRANCE 24 is not liable for any damages whatsoever arising out of the content or use of this blog.
Perhaps Mr Hollande needs to practise of saying less than necessary. However, he is a politician after all.
It's more immature than anything else. I understand it as just a joke, and perhaps the intensity of the response was a little overstated, but it was in poor taste. Interestingly, though, as someone previously mentioned, the left was always quick to point out Sarkozy's faux-pas. I'd say the shoe was on the other foot but I doubt that the Socialists are at all fazed by any criticism from the right. Double standard, indeed.
A bit of jolly humour is a welcome change. Frankly, NKM (la _Princesse_ Nathalie Kosciusko-Morizet) is about as cheerful and gay as a grain-silo door.
The problem is not cracking jokes but rather the socialists behavior when sarkozy showed is lack of taste. There was an uproar from leftist intelligentsia (sic) but I guess now uproars from the right are forbidden since hollande took office. Double standards anyone?

Post new comment

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • No HTML tags allowed

More information about formatting options

This question is for testing whether you are a human visitor and to prevent automated spam submissions.